Written by: Yagmur Erdogmus, Victoria Salazar, Zineb Haddoudi & Nour Halabi
Session contributions and insights by: Sandra Imran Alsouse & Nourjahen Jemaa Westling
(Note: This blog post is a co-created reflection from VOICIFY’s third “Rethinking EU Youth Integration and Political Power” Co-Creation Lab. The insights, quotes, and structural critiques presented below were generated collectively by the participants during our live session.)
In this third session of Rethinking Youth Integration and Political Power, we came together and started the session by reflecting on the challenges and opportunities of our co-creation process. Life is happening at the same time, and we talked about how it is important to try to be mindful and understanding towards how our migration experiences (and related affective and material realities, such as trying to find jobs, renewing residence permits, and being overwhelmed in these processes) may shape participatory dynamics differently across individuals.
Building on this, we started hands-on with our Padlet Photovoice Exhibition. This helped us create a living visual repository of our lived experiences of what participation and integration mean to us as migrants in the EU.
Cultural closeness sometimes can appear in places you least expect…

“For instance, seeing Palestine, the Palestinian product in the Albert Heijn, which is like one of the most famous supermarkets in the Netherlands…I mean, I was really impressed, honestly, but especially because… it’s like it’s sharing a culture. But because it’s like… it’s a very politicized culture. So I was really impressed that cultures can have a place in extremely mainstream European spaces.” (Nour)
Nour further added that: “My takeaway is that participation isn’t equally available to everyone, because when you’re also dealing with job hunting, residence permits, etc., showing up to political spaces is a privilege of time and energy. So self-paced ways to contribute matter a lot.”
Nourjahen shared her thoughts on how she got a tattoo that represents the two cultures she identifies with: Tunisian and Swedish. Transcribing the word “Sumud” in Futhark (an older runic/Viking alphabet) in her tattoo, she further added that “Every year when it’s Midsummer, I wear the same white Tunisian dress. And I have a crown of flowers from Sweden. And for me, that’s how I feel integrated. When I can find ways to bring both cultures together.”

She further noted that migrants are not passive victims only, and integration is indeed a two-way street, addressing the necessity of tackling problematic trends in our migrant communities: such as non-acceptance of LGBTQ+ issues to be taught in classrooms (for children of immigrants).
Sandra’s points echoed Nourjahen as she reminded the importance of integration as genuinely requiring being a two-way street:

“When I posted this, I found it very much interesting when I was attending the World Village Festival because I see integration as something that you, as someone who has this migrant background, are the one who has the duty to integrate into the new society. But often we don’t see it as two ways of integration; that is, the society that is hosting you has also a kind of responsibility, like, to accept you.”
Zineb’s reflection brought us to how the personal and political levels are intertwined when it comes to the integration discourse:
“As a Moroccan who lives in the Netherlands, where the Moroccan community, and there’s a lot of loaded history and discrimination…there’s always this identity question, and for me, the picture I posted is personal, because it’s a daily reminder… It’s from my living room, and it’s a very interesting contrast between outside the street, Dutch people, Dutch culture, and then coming home and then being reminded that parts of my identity don’t have to be solely shaped by Dutch culture (i.e., becoming more Dutch, or as the right-wing government here puts it: adhering to the norms and values of Dutch society)
So this is very, very personal…integration for me is like wanting to put you in just one box. And it took so much time to be like, ‘okay, but I don’t fit only in one box; I have so many parts of my identity. And these books and authors and topics are proof of that”

Power Mapping: Decision-making behind the definition of integration
Following our visual reflections on what integration means and feels like to us, we looked into two different policy fragments that connect to how integration is defined in “official” terms: The EU Commission Action Plan on Integration and Inclusion 2021–2027 and The European Council’s EU Youth Strategy 2019–2027, based on the European Council Resolution of 26 November 2018.

Then we mapped stakeholders, defining the official discourse on “integration” into three zones:
- Inner Room: Decision-makers who write policies.
- Hallway: Those who can hear the decisions and attempt to influence them (e.g., NGOs, some experts)
- Outside: Those heavily impacted by rules but with no say in their creation.

Systemic Failures
Participants noted that even when experts or stakeholders are in the “hallway,” their research and opinions are often ignored by those in the “inner room”: they are not heard. As Nourjahen powerfully summarised, “the hallway is super full, but no one is listening in the inner room.”
“A prime example is occurring in Sweden, where the government pushed for increased police presence in migrant areas, actively ignoring the actual police chief who publicly recommended investing in social workers instead. It seems the hallway is becoming ‘blurrier’ across the EU: the space for dialogue exists in theory, but genuine listening does not.
The most concrete example of being stuck “outside the building” is the residency permit system. It is a structure that heavily dictates the material realities, anxieties, and daily lives of almost everyone in the session, yet it is designed and implemented completely without their input.” (Nourjahen)
Right-Wing Impact, Shrinking of Civic Space: Integration as a Scapegoat
In a related way, participants also reflected on the recent political shifts across Europe, specifically from the contexts of Finland and Sweden, bringing the metaphor of the inaccessibility of the Inner Room into how these may impact our material realities.
Sandra, for instance, talked about the radical changes regarding the citizenship law, as well as the NGO funding cuts in Sweden, especially following the right-wing government, which she noted the people voted for. Both Sandra and Nourhajan mentioned how these cuts are not just affecting people with multicultural and migration backgrounds who benefit from these NGOs, but also impacting locals who, for example, make a living from these organizations by working in them.
“Now they have to find another job because the government decided that they don’t want to fund integration work, and they have cut about 80 million Euros.” (Sandra)
Nourjahen continued by mentioning how “PeaceWorks Sweden had to shut down offices in two countries because the government decided that our NGO vision does not fit the government’s NGO vision, and our vision is… Global justice. Feminism. And inclusion. And the government was like, you guys do not match our vision, and they cut our funding, so now we had to shut down the NGO. PeaceWorks has been in Sweden for 50 years, 52 years this year, and everyone had to be fired, and all Erasmus projects stopped because of that.”
For Brussels, Nour points out how they think the hallway is significantly shrinking.
“The funding issue is definitely prominent here too. Many organisations are now losing the resources that keep them there. For instance, the Humanitarian Hub has lost half its funding since April and had to halve its team and temporarily close. Belgium is cutting its development cooperation budget by 25%. Participation takes time as well as expertise and stable staff, so when funding goes, the ability to take part in decisions goes with it. I think organisations are not just ignored in the hallway; they are actually being slowly moved out of it.” (Nour)
Nour adds that the people most affected by these decisions are so far away from the room where it is decided, supported by organisations that are themselves losing capacity. In brief, it goes without saying that the rise of the right-wing in Brussels as well as the EU in general is extremely alarming: migrants are viewed as the “black sheep” and are held responsible for wider social and economic problems, which makes it easier to justify cutting the services and organisations that support them.
The Netherlands is also not much better. Zineb points out how the “hallway” metaphor raises important questions: who is invited to speak, and whose input actually influences decisions? Civil society organisations can create opportunities for participation, but being consulted does not necessarily mean being heard. People with migration backgrounds may be asked to share their experiences while still having little influence over how problems are defined or which solutions are considered.
“What concerns me is how discussions about integration can place the responsibility to change mainly on individuals, rather than also examining discrimination, institutional barriers, and unequal access to opportunities. This can leave people feeling that they must constantly prove they belong, even when they are already contributing to society.
In this sense, a shrinking civic space is also about whose knowledge is valued and whether disagreement is welcome. If organisations feel pressure to soften their criticism to preserve access or support, the hallway may still exist, but its ability to challenge decisions in the inner room becomes weaker. Meaningful participation would require more than inviting people into a discussion: their input would need to have a visible effect on the decisions that shape their lives.” (Zineb)
We finished off by reflecting on how these are unfortunately trends in the EU at the moment, not just particular isolated cases; our personal lives, histories, stories, and lived realities are scapegoated in the name of preserving the “culture” or “society” which actually thrives through differences if resources are allocated fairly.
Looking at our final map of the building, if you could send one direct, unfiltered message to the decision-makers currently sitting in the ‘inner room’, what would it be?
*Disclaimer: The opinions and views expressed in this blog post are entirely those of the co-authors and contributing participants. They do not necessarily reflect the official policies, positions, or views of VOICIFY or its affiliated member organizations. VOICIFY provides the Co-Creation Labs as a platform for youth with lived migration experiences to safely share their insights and shape narratives.


